Dr. Edward Rosenthal

Edward Rosenthal, M.D

Vouch or leave a review for Dr. Rosenthal!

North Shore-Lij Medical PC
850 Hicksville Rd, Suite 104
Seaford, NY 11783 (Directions)

(516) 798-0141

1.1 out of 5

North Shore-Lij Medical PC
850 Hicksville Rd, Suite 104
Seaford, NY 11783 (Directions)

(516) 798-0141

Reviews here and beyond

Rating and reviews

1.1 out of 5

6 ratings, 6 reviews

I will make this short and to the point. Dr. Rosenthal and his office staff earn a one start rating at best. Dr. Rosenthal is always running extremely late. So when He does come into the room to see you, He is gone in a flash. I had to follow him out of the room several times asking question while he rushes off to the next appointment. The office staff is horrific with communication also.

RateMds User

April 13 , 2022

This is the worst doctor ever. For years my husband was bleeding blood clots the size of half dollars, he kept putting him in the hospital for biopsys ,telling him I forgot a tool you have to come back for another biopsy, this went on for four years. His conclusion was it is his anatomy to get over it and live with it that it’s not cancer. So I find a new doctor and my husband is in fourth stage bladder cancer. Dr. Rosenthal didn’t care at all he didn’t want us to have any information he didn’t want my daughter to have any information he just didn’t care. Four years of bleeding every test came back with mucus in the way you think he would look at the mucosal lining of his bladder. Instead he kept on adding new surgeries by saying he doesn’t have the tool he needs. He’s just a big liar. He’s also unprofessional I hear him yell at the girls while I’m sitting in the office screaming. He put my husband on the same antibiotic three times that he’s allergic to. Now because he told my husband he doesn’t have cancer my husband thought he was OK. But I got him a new dr anyways and it’s not his anatomy he has cancer . His bladder and prostrate has been removed and he’s in chemo. This moron was leaving him to die . He dragged it out so long I hope My husband Willl be ok. It went into his lymph nodes wasting all this time with rosenthal .he screamed at my hubby to not let myself and my daughter have access to his medical . He shouldn’t even have a license He’s a disgrace to all urologist around the world

Vitals User

May 21 , 2022

Dismissive, unhelpful, didn't care at all

Vitals User

August 20 , 2022

If I could leave 0 stars, I would. Horrific.

Vitals User

February 24 , 2023

I will make this short and to the point. Dr. Rosenthal and his office staff earn a one star rating at best. Dr. Rosenthal is always running extremely late. So when He does come into the room to see you, He is gone in a flash. I had to follow him out of the room several times asking question while he rushes off to the next appointment. The office staff is horrific with communication also.

WebMD User

April 22 , 2022

"He treated my husband for four years while my husband bled from his penis toilet bowls full of blood. He tells my daughter your father is gonna die just not today he has no cancer. He tells my husband it’s your anatomy you’re gonna have to live with it. We got a new doctor and found fourth stage bladder cancer in my husband, he now has no bladder no prostrate and he was positive in the lymph nodes ..."